Multi-touch trackpads – just a gimmick or what?!

Multi-touch trackpads – seems like every computer manufacturer nowadays has several models touting them. But having used multi-touch trackpads for several weeks now, as well as a ‘single touch’ trackpad for my own notebook, I’m wondering right now if multi-touch trackpads are just a gimmick. Seems I love single touch trackpads because I don’t have to shift my entire right hand each time I want to do something.

  • Tapping and clicking – Both single and multi-touch trackpads can do these.
  • Scrolling – Single-touch trackpads typically have scroll zones on the right side – having ‘average’ sized hands, I can easily reach for the scroll zone using my thumb without moving my entire hand off the keyboard. Nice when I just want to scroll down… say a Word document… and continue typing. In contrast, multi-touch trackpads need me to move my entire hand down to operate the ‘two finger scroll’ function. What an inconvenience. (Yes I have tried ‘dual thumb’ scrolling before but it’s awkward)
  • Zooming – Yes, we’ve all heard about the famous ‘pinch zoom’ function of multi-touch devices ever since the iPhone made its debut in 2007… but that still needs two fingers and hand-shifting. Before multi-touch trackpads became mainstream on consumer notebooks, I believe I survived just fine (and better) using the mentioned scroll-zone for zooming, or in Firefox/IE, Ctrl+scroll-zone. By now you would have figured that the scroll zone does the exact same thing as your conventional mouse wheel (in case you didn’t know).
    Pinch zooming is certainly important on a device lacking buttons, and to conserve ‘space’ (ie, on a multi-touch display). But on a trackpad, I’d say zooming is not something that deserves its own ‘gesture’/control. It’s not like the keyboard +/- keys or existing scroll-zone didn’t do its job well enough to be replaced by multi-touch.
  • Rotation – Fine, this is a multi-touch trackpad exclusive, and not available on single-touch trackpads. But then again, I didn’t know the world REALLY had to have a rotate function implemented directly into the trackpad. If I wanted to rotate a photo, I’d hit the ‘rotate left’ or ‘rotate right’ icon in Photo Viewer. If I wanted to rotate a whole bunch of photos, I’d use the batch processing feature in Photoshop.
  • Chiral scrolling – Technically this is a function that only needs one finger… yet it’s strange that only ‘newer’ (multi-t0uch) trackpads can do this. Again, it doesn’t do anything that the single-touch scroll zone can’t do.

To sum things up, I really don’t think that multi-touch trackpads are a crucial feature or dealbreaker when it comes to shopping for a notebook. In fact, I’d take a single-touch trackpad over a multi-touch one anytime (apparently HP thinks that too with their business notebooks). Sure, multi-touch trackpads are nice to have and cool to show off, but they get old after a while (and it’s not like they make existing tasks like rotation or zooming any easier). A buddy of mine wanted to go back to a ‘normal’ trackpad after two weeks with the multi-touch trackpad on his new Envy 15. Another guy I know who loved talking about the ‘coolness’ of multi-touch recently changed his mind after spending time with his new Asus notebook’s multi-touch trackpad.

Add a Comment

  • *

Your email address will never be published or shared.

Content copyright 2008-2020 HP Fansite. All rights reserved.
All trademarks and images are property of their respective owners.
This site is not affiliated with the Hewlett Packard Company, HP or
Views expressed by reader comments do not reflect that of HP or HP Fansite
Web design by Brad S (32/0.713)